Getting The Mind To Steer The Body To Steer You
AIThis post was created with the assistance of artificial intelligence (AI).

TL;DR

A personal essay argues that mental cues can sometimes alter bodily responses when reasoning or willpower alone does not seem to work. It draws on anecdotes about cravings, pain, sleep and stress, but does not establish that these methods work reliably or explain the mechanisms involved.

An essay titled “Getting the mind to steer the body to steer you” argues that people may sometimes change bodily responses through specific mental cues, rather than through reasoning or willpower alone. The writer illustrates the idea with personal experiences and accounts involving cravings, pain, sleep and stress, while offering no controlled evidence that the techniques work generally or identifying a verified mechanism.

Before you orderOffer from Amazon

Get oils, diffusers and self-care delivered free with Prime

  • Fast, free delivery on millions of items
  • Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
  • Member-only deals all year
Start your free Prime trial Free trial for eligible customers · Cancel anytime
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.

The writer recalls hearing, as a child, adults praise Allen Carr’s book The Easy Way to Stop Smoking as a way to quit smoking. The writer, who says they had never smoked, imagined that the book might help by reframing a craving as a temporary urge rather than evidence that smoking itself was desirable. Years later, the writer says a similar approach helped reduce cravings for sweets after meals. This is a personal account, not evidence that the same approach works for other people or for nicotine dependence.

The essay also describes stories about readers who felt better after encountering books about trauma or pain. It recounts Scott Alexander’s account of a severely traumatized patient who, after reading The Body Keeps the Score, reported feeling cured the following week despite not trying the book’s techniques. The essay gives no further clinical details or independent confirmation of that case.

For back pain, the writer refers to John Sarno’s Healing Back Pain: The Mind-Body Connection and to an August 2022 post by Patrick Collison saying the book had worked for four people he knew. A reply to Collison’s post described relief after reading online reviews of the book. The essay presents these accounts as examples of perceived change, not as proof of a treatment effect. The writer’s own examples include using a watch and body-scanning as a way to fall asleep, and imagining the body filling with air to feel less tense.

At a glance
reportWhen: Published in an undated essay; the cite…
The developmentA writer’s essay examines anecdotes and personal experiences in which a mental cue appeared to change a physical or emotional response.

Why Mental Cues Draw Interest

The essay speaks to a practical frustration: knowing what one wants to do does not always make the body cooperate. A person may understand that a craving will pass, want to sleep, or want to relax, yet find that direct commands and abstract reasoning do little. The writer’s proposed distinction is between telling oneself what to feel and using a concrete cue that changes attention or bodily sensation.

That distinction may help readers describe their own experiences and consider low-risk ways of directing attention. But anecdotes cannot show whether a cue caused the improvement, whether the effect would last, or whether it would apply beyond the person describing it. The examples also involve very different issues, from everyday stress to debilitating pain and trauma. They should not be taken to mean that serious symptoms are imaginary, that a person can resolve them by thinking differently, or that medical care is unnecessary.

Products Worth Considering

Philips Sonicare DiamondClean 9500 Electric Toothbrush, Black, with 3 Brush Heads

Philips Sonicare DiamondClean 9500 Electric Toothbrush, Black, with 3 Brush Heads

Withings Body Smart Accurate Scale for Body Weight, Fat Percentage and Body Composition

Withings Body Smart Accurate Scale for Body Weight, Fat Percentage and Body Composition

As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.

The Essay’s Examples and Sources

The piece is a first-person essay published by the Substack publication not not Talmud. Its evidence is a mixture of the writer’s recollections, personal experiences and reported anecdotes. It does not present a research study, patient records, or a systematic review of the books and claims it discusses.

The essay links its examples through a proposed feedback loop: discomfort may prompt worry and increased attention, which may contribute to tension and further distress. It suggests that changing how a person interprets or attends to a sensation might interrupt that loop. This is the writer’s account of how the examples could fit together; the article does not demonstrate that explanation or establish that it accounts for the reported outcomes.

The references to Collison’s post and its replies are dated August 17, 2022. The essay also notes that the writer later found their childhood theory resembled the “craving” idea in Carr’s book. That resemblance is part of the writer’s retrospective account, not an independent evaluation of the book’s effectiveness.

““[The book] had worked for 4 out of 4 people I knew who tried it.””

— Patrick Collison, in a post cited by the essay

What the Anecdotes Cannot Establish

The essay does not establish whether the reported changes were caused by reading, imagery, altered attention, expectation, time, other treatment, or some combination. It provides no controlled comparisons, clinical assessments, or follow-up showing how long the changes lasted. The precise experiences of the patient described by Scott Alexander and the people Collison knew are not independently documented in the source material.

It is also unclear how broadly the writer’s suggested techniques apply, or whether they are suitable for particular conditions. The essay’s discussion of pain and trauma should not be read as a diagnosis or treatment recommendation. Persistent pain, significant distress, sleep problems or substance dependence may warrant advice from a qualified health professional.

No Study or Follow-Up Reported

The source material reports no new study, clinical trial, medical guidance or follow-up testing these ideas. It leaves the proposed mind-body feedback loop as an interpretation of personal and secondhand experiences. Readers should distinguish that argument from established evidence about any specific treatment and seek professional guidance for serious or persistent symptoms.

Key Questions

What is the essay’s main argument?

The writer argues that a specific mental cue may sometimes influence a bodily response when reasoning or willpower alone does not seem to help. The claim is based on personal experience and anecdotes, not a controlled study.

Does the essay prove that reading a book can cure pain or trauma?

No. It recounts reports of people feeling better after reading books or reviews, but does not provide clinical records, independent verification or evidence establishing what caused the improvement.

What examples does the writer give from personal experience?

The writer says a way of thinking about cravings helped with sweets after meals, and describes using timed body-scanning to fall asleep and balloon imagery to feel less tense. These are personal accounts, not demonstrated treatments.

What remains unknown about the proposed approach?

The source does not establish how the reported effects occurred, how long they lasted, whether they would work for others, or whether the same explanation fits cravings, pain, sleep and stress.

Source: notnottalmud.substack.com

Wellness content on this site is informational and not a substitute for professional medical guidance.
You May Also Like

Essential Oils to Repel Gnats in Houseplants

With the right essential oils, you can naturally repel gnats from your houseplants—discover how to create an effective spray that works wonders.

Roll Into Relaxation: DIY Aromatherapy Roll-Ons That Calm in a Flash!

You can create your own soothing aromatherapy roll-ons, but what unique blends will help you relax even faster? Discover the secrets inside!